Purrs In Our Hearts - Cat Forum UK

Cat Rescue & Rehoming => Adopt/Give a home to a cat => Topic started by: Debbie on September 13, 2009, 15:13:52 PM

Title: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home
Post by: Debbie on September 13, 2009, 15:13:52 PM
Hi

I lost my cat 2 years ago, he was only 2 at the time and I didnt feel I could take on another cat until now.  Anyway I have been to see two cats today and I really am torn as to which one.  I'm looking for opinions.

The first is a ginger boy, very affectionate.  He apparantly is very laid back and a bit lazy as he sleeps mostly during the day but when I saw him he was very alert and came out of the pen to greet me.  The second is a shy female, very affectionate too.  They are both aged 5 and lived together but the rescue has since realised they dont really get on as the boy bullied the girl so they want to get her to come out of her shell, which she did when I went into the pen, she came out of her housebed for strokes and was purring and licking my hand.

So, I work and there will be no-one in the house for 4 days a week.  I wouldnt want them out whilst I was at work but if they did not come back before I left I have a catflap into my shed as a bit of shelter and I would put a bed in there.  Dont think the female would want that somehow, and its likely she would only go out for short periods if at all.  The male though, I've only ever had males that wanted to go out.  Not sure if he would just sleep as they said or want to go/stay out?

They were left behind when the owners moved house so they cannot tell me if they were indoor/outdoor.  I dont know which one would be better to live with me....
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Kay and Penny on September 13, 2009, 15:25:05 PM
I'm not sure anyone can answer this question for you, Debbie

all I can say is, if I couldn't choose between two cats needing homes, I would adopt the one I and the rescue thought the less likely to be homed by someone else, and/or the one doing less well in its current placement
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Sootyca on September 13, 2009, 15:34:47 PM
Agree with Trigger, only you can decide and I would go for the one that could be harder to rehome....and if they are both the same I would pick the cutest! LOL!

At 5 they are probably both content to be lazing around all day. I wouldn't be too worried about the boy wanting to be out a lot.... not all boys do.  Mine is never happier than when he is snuggled on a bed, even in summer!  And when it is winter, well, we are lucky if he is out for more than 15 minutes!  It was the girl who was always out regardless of the weather or temperature!

The girl cat may be more of a "project" - may need more work to get her confidence up and if you are out a lot it may not be ideal.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 13, 2009, 15:36:24 PM
Fair comment, I thought I would get a similar reply.  I always seem to want them all when I get there.

I'll think it over and then if they are reserved in the meantime then they werent the one for me.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: woodlandcats on September 13, 2009, 18:04:23 PM
You are very lucky just having to choose between two! When I went to look for a cat to adopt, there were about 15 and I nearly cried, so difficult it was.
Years ago when I went to the shelter to have a little calico, there was mum calico with two calico babies and I would have loved  to take them all three but neutering 3 females, couldn't afford it.
So I had this woman taking the two kittens in her hands behind her back and then put one on the table. Out came Noa, not my first choice in appearance, but she turned out such a sweet darling!!
So let your heart decide and I think fate has it's own way.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Teresa Pawcats on September 13, 2009, 18:20:09 PM
Before I began rescue work I went to the kennels seeking a rescue dog, when I arrived i couldnt look at the dogs I merely said " Give me the one thats been here the longest that nobone else wants" I took Winnie home there and then and began my rescue work less than a week later, should add at that point I was terrified of cats we soon overcame that.
Good Luck with your decision.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Kittybabe (Ruth) on September 13, 2009, 18:46:21 PM
I was terrified of cats we soon overcame that.

And have you ever!!!
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 13, 2009, 18:53:34 PM
I am glad it's not only me then Woodlandcats.  Whilst I was there I was in and out of each pen as I couldnt make up my mind.  The guy said he always brings out one puppy when a female is there choosing her new dog, if he brings out any more and she has to choose he is there all day!  I kinda had to agree with him...

I think I'm erring on the the boy cat, I've always had boys and he was just so big and gorgeous he was like a cuddly bear!  when I was looking at the female he meowed in the pen behind me as if to say hey dont forget I'm still here!
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Tiggy's Mum on September 13, 2009, 23:41:56 PM
 :welcome: back Debbie, I remember when Sam went missing  :hug: Glad you've felt able to let another furball into your life  :hug:

Whichever one you choose they'll be the lucky one that's for sure  :)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Bazsmum on September 14, 2009, 00:35:32 AM
:welcome: back Debbie, I remember when Sam went missing  :hug: Glad you've felt able to let another furball into your life  :hug:

Whichever one you choose they'll be the lucky one that's for sure  :)

Seconded from me!  :Luv: :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Corporal Smokey on September 14, 2009, 10:15:34 AM
 :shify: There really is only one solution here...

take them both  ;)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Bazsmum on September 15, 2009, 02:43:58 AM
I thought that too Amy!  :sneaky: ;) :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 16, 2009, 20:37:35 PM
I have since been told they will not re-home me only one cat as I am at work during the day.  So I went to see them both today and whilst they dont fight they dont bother with each other neither so I am not sure why I have to have them both instead of only one as I think they would still be 'lonely' even if I took them both if one was always in and one was out?

I hadnt really planned on having two and I'm not sure my finances could cover having two so I was dithering on the phone to her when she said actually they had a reserve on them anyway!  Not sure if she was saying that to get me to decide or put me off altogether as she said the person whom had reserved them would take any pair of cats they had in...

So I went another shelter and they said they would only rehome me a cat over 5yo that they knew would be ok left alone for long hours.  Another one wanted me to have a cat flap into the house which I cannot have as it is a patio door.  I am surprised anyone gets to rehome cats these days with all these conditions.  I totally understand that it would be quite solitary to be left alone each day but I thought cats slept more than humans?  That was the reason I was looking for an adult cat (5yrs+). 

I think I better put it on a backburner until I work part time or win the lottery and dont have to work altogether....
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Kay and Penny on September 16, 2009, 20:46:34 PM
this saddens me, and is not the first time someone has been put off by too many conditions IMO

I have twice had a sole kitten which I left at home alone five days a week whilst I worked full time - neither came to any harm, or had any behavioural problems

and neither Tiffany or Trigger would mind at all if the other disappeared tomorrow, even though they have shared this house for 6 years
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Tiggy's Mum on September 16, 2009, 20:49:14 PM
That's disappointing  :( I iknow they only have the cats' best interest at heart but how many single adult cats are there in households where people work full time - I'd hazard a guess it's a very large majority!

There's quite a few cat from rescues on Purrs needing homes - Polish sounds like a gorgeous boy...

http://www.purrsinourhearts.co.uk/index.php/topic,27690.0.html

Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Christine (Blip) on September 16, 2009, 20:54:37 PM
I am so sad to hear this: OH and I both work a lot more than full time - and always have done - and our Blip is happy and well-adjusted.  Try another rescue  :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 16, 2009, 21:05:26 PM
Thanks for your replies, I was starting to think I was being unreasonable in my expectations of re-homing a cat as I've been to 3 separate shelters now and each have their own different conditions.  I got home and was so upset, as after the second time of seeing the male cat again I really fell for his charm   :(
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: LadyJane on September 16, 2009, 21:11:03 PM
We both work full time too and Samson seems fine with that arrangement.  He's such a pampered puss when we are at home that I think he secretly likes his 8 hour break from all that fuss :evillaugh:

Definately approach other rescues or see if there's anyone listed on here who could be your next feline friend.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Kay and Penny on September 16, 2009, 21:44:58 PM
I wonder if the rescue you went to first was trying it on a bit with you, Debbie, as they sensed an opportunity to rehome two cats

I would be inclined to go back and say you definitely want the male cat and only the male cat, like it or lump it - I think it might well work :sneaky:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Gill (sneakiefeline) on September 16, 2009, 21:48:52 PM
this is so shortsighted of those rescues and i also wonder if they are seriosuly trying to rehome. do not give up but do make sure you know all conditionsa before looking at cats, so you dont lose heart  :hug: :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Janeyk on September 16, 2009, 22:03:05 PM
I can never decide which cat either before we got Pepper there were so many needing homes and if I go to a rescue I always go for oldies but I'm like Teresa was and always say which is overlooked and least likely to get a home, I hate seeing them all because I can't stop thinking about them.  Whilst I was undecided over a few Pepper came up he was to be pts and so I enquired about him and he has been with us 7wks now.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 16, 2009, 22:08:52 PM
I thought so too Trigger which is why I went back a second time then telephoned the rescue again today (the cats are off site in a cattery).  I did try all my powers of persuasion to get just the male cat but she was adamant she would only re-home me two, no matter if they were close or not which kind of defeats the object really if they are not close with each other IMO.

Gill I spoke with the rescue people first before I went to see the cats and they said they could go separate as they werent close.  It was only after I had been to see the cats that I was asked about my working hours and then the about-turn on only offering me both.

I wont, but it makes me want to be economical with the truth of how much I'm out during the day  :shify:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Kay and Penny on September 16, 2009, 22:13:18 PM
I think that's so wrong  >:(- I would be really worried about leaving two cats who were strangers to each other in the house while I was out - what if one really bullied the other?


Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Gill (sneakiefeline) on September 16, 2009, 22:17:00 PM
I think some of this  :shify: :shify: :shify: may be helpful  ;)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Tiggy's Mum on September 16, 2009, 22:48:51 PM
This has really bothered me and it doesn't even affect me! I've been home tonight and my 2 x two year olds (brothers, who do get on/love each other) have spent the last 5 hours curled up in separate spots snoozing the night away, and that's with me being home - I would imagine they have done the same during the 9 hours I was at work!

I think it's really sad that they're denying another cat the same pleasure  :( I do think that in the case of young kittens with full time working owners that it's much better to go in pairs and in an ideal world adult cats would have a cat friend to share the home with (if they were cat friendly) but it's so short sighted to knock back what otherwise sounds like a great, loving home just because you're out at work full time >:(
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Bazsmum on September 17, 2009, 00:22:19 AM
Aw! Dont let this bad experience put you off Debbie....There are lots of cats and rescues looking for a purrrfect cat mum like you!  :hug: :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Dawn F on September 17, 2009, 09:16:35 AM
how riduclous, keeping a cat costs money and so you need a job, this is just the sort of thing that sends people to petshops and freeads
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Corporal Smokey on September 17, 2009, 09:56:55 AM
IMHO each cat is different and each home is different so it seems a bit red-tapey to have such strict rules.

One rescue I know has the most adorable little deaf white cat in their care. She's very playful and friendly, the kind of cat you'd love to see playing with responsible kids. However this cat won't be allowed to go where there are any kids under any circumstances because "you can guarantee the kids will let her out and she'll get run over because she's deaf".

I know rescues have the cats' interests at heart but seeing this bouncy little thing in a pen does upset me a bit.

Whereabouts are you Debbie? If you're in Derbyshire, come and see the cats at Ashfield ;-) , subject to usual homechecks I'm sure we could match you up!

Have a look at http://www.catchat.org/topcats too  :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Bazsmum on September 17, 2009, 15:02:43 PM
how riduclous, keeping a cat costs money and so you need a job, this is just the sort of thing that sends people to petshops and freeads

Here, here....and what a sickener for any rescue on here to view as Im sure they would agree that they are laying a path to those ads because of their silly standards!  :Crazy:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 17, 2009, 21:12:28 PM
Hi Amy

I am quite far from Derbyshire, im nr Manchester in Cheshire. He's probably not there anymore but Charlie looked lush on the Catchat page of yours, he is similar to the one I was refused  :)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Christine (Blip) on September 17, 2009, 21:33:50 PM
Debbie

Why not send Teresa (Pawcats) a PM?  She's in Weaverham.  Her standards are the highest but she's not doctrinaire  :hug:

www.pawsinncats.com
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Liz on September 17, 2009, 21:59:35 PM
Paws Inn Cats are gorgeous and have the added bonus of Minipop training and of course all the love and care Auntie T gives them and if you aren't faraway from Aunty T then go to Paws Inn master Ripley came from there and Garcia is on my kidnap list!
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Dawn F on September 18, 2009, 09:55:19 AM
couldn't agree more - Teresa is an absolute life saver for homeless kitties
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Corporal Smokey on September 18, 2009, 11:31:51 AM
Hmmm Charlie does appear to have been on there an awful long time. He's certainly not at the shelter anymore but I'm wondering if he's not been taken down due to being in foster care. I'll check for you over the weekend and the page will be fully updated next week.

I'd third, fourth and fifth the idea of a Paws Inn resident for you. I'm sure it's better for you and your new pusscat to be in the same area.

If Charlie is still available you'd probably just need to get a local CP check done but I do have a feeling he might have just slipped thorugh the net and is probably curled up on someone's bed by now.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Sootyca on September 18, 2009, 22:36:49 PM
How about Mika who is currently with Bonnielass and would prefer a home without other cats.......well, it's worth a try pointing her out!

http://www.purrsinourhearts.co.uk/index.php/topic,27115.0.html

There are so many deserving cases around I'm sure you'll find the perfect match.

Karen
x
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Tiggy's Mum on September 19, 2009, 14:05:48 PM
I know he's quite far away but Timmy is the right age frame and looks adorable  :Luv:

http://www.purrsinourhearts.co.uk/index.php/topic,27862.0.html
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Gill (sneakiefeline) on September 19, 2009, 14:34:11 PM
timmy sounds ideal and has been sorted by a vet and everything  ;D
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 23, 2009, 11:57:47 AM
Timmy is lovely but he is in Gloucester  :-:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Dawn F on September 23, 2009, 11:58:12 AM
if they can travel we can get them there!!!!
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 23, 2009, 12:06:22 PM
Really?  I would definitely be interested then.  I could travel so far to collect him but Gloucester there and back in a day was a bit much for me.
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Bazsmum on September 23, 2009, 12:10:26 PM
 :shify: :wow:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 23, 2009, 12:12:29 PM
I've sent the poster of Timmy a pm as I have a few questions  :)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Gill (sneakiefeline) on September 23, 2009, 12:56:29 PM
sounds promising  ;D
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: JackSpratt on September 23, 2009, 13:01:56 PM
Did you decide Tarzan was too far away then, Debbie? (Sorry, not hounding you - just thought you'd look at this thread more than Tarzans.)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 23, 2009, 14:03:24 PM
Hi

I left my details about Tarzan following your message but nobody contacted me.  I've been in touch with the poster of Timmy and I'm just waiting for a further response.  I dont want to mess people about so it's now probably best I wait until she gets back to me with her reply first.

Thanks for asking though  :shy:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Dawn F on September 23, 2009, 14:44:52 PM
hope you get sorted soon either way if you don't hear back from anyone I'd contact pawsinn, Teresa is very speedy at getting back to people!!
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Tiggy's Mum on September 23, 2009, 16:23:53 PM
:wish: Have everything crossed for you and whichever lucky cat you choose!
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Janeyk on September 23, 2009, 18:49:51 PM
Good luck Debbie!
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: JackSpratt on September 23, 2009, 21:54:34 PM
Debbie, if you are interested in Tarzan PM me your phone number and I'll send it to Nicky. She's really busy but tends to read my emails pretty quickly due to me doing her site for her. ;)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on September 24, 2009, 22:43:21 PM
Hi JS

I've pm'ed you my details  :)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Bazsmum on September 24, 2009, 23:47:05 PM
 :allears: and  :crossed:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Gill (sneakiefeline) on September 25, 2009, 00:11:12 AM
I do hope you are successful this time Debbie  :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Bazsmum on September 27, 2009, 14:41:13 PM
I hear there may be a maybe on this one!  :wow: :hug:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on October 04, 2009, 17:35:07 PM
This thread can now be locked, as I now have a new cat  :)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Christine (Blip) on October 04, 2009, 17:37:30 PM
This thread can now be locked, as I now have a new cat  :)

That's great.  Could I ask you to share your good news?  :wow:
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Gill (sneakiefeline) on October 04, 2009, 17:43:16 PM
We dont lock threads on Purrs unless there is a problem and dont think this sounds like a problem at all  ;D
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home - help
Post by: Debbie on October 04, 2009, 17:46:05 PM
Oops ok thanks Gill.

The link to my new kitty is here:

http://www.purrsinourhearts.co.uk/index.php/topic,27821.0.html

 :)
Title: Re: Torn between choosing which cat to re-home
Post by: JackSpratt on October 27, 2009, 11:38:40 AM
Debbie.....we're still waiting for pictures! ;)